dT

[email protected] (The Doctor)

18/04/2010 9:30 AM

And in North America here comes the review wave of 11th Hour and possible spoilers

I say 9.5 / 10 .


The crash landing TADRIS and the Doctor finds himself in the 1990s with a little
girl.

Hey, Moffat, thank for the respect in Faith. Nice touch.

Please do not make the mistake RTD did in Gridlock whne he outright
mocked Christianity.

The Crack. Prisoner Zero. Silence will Follow! The eye!

Moffat great start!!

I wonder did Amy cricket bat the Doctor or did Prisoner 0?

Nice touch about the comatose people walking around.

That kept me hooked in.

Looses end include how did Prisoner 0 escape and what are causing these
cracks?

Hey great stuff for the Doctor to come up with the 0 virus and
prevent Earth from getting obliterated.

Poor Amy, she was not crazy and now she benefits.

So the Aliens gets a boot and the Doctor is confirmed.

Love the flashbacks and the memory of Spearhead in space PArt 1.

Matt Smith too Young, nope!!

OVerall here is the question, can Smith top Tennant and Baker?


--
Member - Liberal International This is [email protected] Ici [email protected]
God, Queen and country! Never Satan President Republic! Beware AntiChrist rising!
http://twitter.com/rootnl2k http://www.facebook.com/dyadallee
UK Time for a Common Sense change vote Liberal Democrat / Alliance


This topic has 2 replies

SW

"Stephen Wilson"

in reply to [email protected] (The Doctor) on 18/04/2010 9:30 AM

19/04/2010 2:58 PM

"The Doctor" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]
>
> Hey, Moffat, thank for the respect in Faith. Nice touch.

Faith? I don't remember seeing her. Or do you mean faith as in a religious
faith? Again, not sure what you mean.

> Please do not make the mistake RTD did in Gridlock whne he outright
> mocked Christianity.

Nobody mocked Christianity in Gridlock. You're making that bit up.

> The Crack. Prisoner Zero. Silence will Follow! The eye!

What about them?

> I wonder did Amy cricket bat the Doctor or did Prisoner 0?

Try watching the episode. It's pretty explicit.

> Nice touch about the comatose people walking around.

Why's that a nice touch?

> That kept me hooked in.

Oh. Is that the only reason you carried on watching? Besides, I don't
actually remember seeing any comatose people walking around. The comatose
people were in a coma. Unconscious. In a hospital ward.

> Looses end include how did Prisoner 0 escape and what are causing these
> cracks?

Was there more than one crack? And it's not so much a loose end (or even a
looses end), more an on-going issue.

> Hey great stuff for the Doctor to come up with the 0 virus and
> prevent Earth from getting obliterated.

Not particularly. I thought it was a cop-out. The way it was achieved
couldn't be accomplished in reality (speed he wrote the virus (on a mobile
phone to boot), speed it travelled around the globe, the way it affected
mechanical clocks!!, the assumption the aliens would even register what was
happening, let alone be bothered to trace the source of the virus, etc etc.)

> Poor Amy, she was not crazy and now she benefits.

I suppose it's a benefit not being crazy, yes...

> So the Aliens gets a boot and the Doctor is confirmed.

What sort of boot? Think I missed that. Was it a Wellington? And I also
missed the bit where the Doctor was confirmed. Was it a Church of England
ceremony?

> Love the flashbacks and the memory of Spearhead in space PArt 1.

Which ones? Do you mean the series of photographs showing what the Doctor
remembered? Do you mean the images of previous Doctors? And which memory of
Spearhead from Space are you talking about?

> OVerall here is the question, can Smith top Tennant and Baker?

Top them in what way? Not sure I get your question here.

SO

"Stephen O'Connell"

in reply to [email protected] (The Doctor) on 18/04/2010 9:30 AM

19/04/2010 2:24 PM

"The Doctor" <[email protected]> wrote
>
> I wonder did Amy cricket bat the Doctor or did Prisoner 0?

Did you watch the show Dave? It's quite clear who belted the Doctor
with the bat!

> Looses end include how did Prisoner 0 escape and what are causing
> these cracks?

As mentioned, that is the ongoing theme of this first Matt Smith
season. The crack and it's effects on Amy (etc.) will feature in
forthcoming episodes.

> Matt Smith too Young, nope!!

He's not too young. You can either do the job or you can't. For me
Matt Smith is doing the job okay. Others may disagree, and that's
fine. I may not have liked all of the three episodes so far, but I do
like his quirky portrayal of the Doctor. It's very Troughton-ish at
times.

> OVerall here is the question, can Smith top Tennant and Baker?

Probably not Dave. But then again I didn't think that David Tennant
would become as iconic as the Doctor as he was. So who knows, Matt
Smith has only had three episodes shown so far (in the UK) so it's way
too early to judge. Ask again in three years time!


You’ve reached the end of replies